Tumblr crosspost (1 February 2025)
May. 1st, 2025 11:37 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Characterization poll responses part 2!
The original Tumblr poll got over 500 notes and over 1000 votes, so I can't realistically compile everything, but I did want to include some that I particularly appreciated. I'm organizing them by subject for convenience.
The original Tumblr poll got over 500 notes and over 1000 votes, so I can't realistically compile everything, but I did want to include some that I particularly appreciated. I'm organizing them by subject for convenience.
As a lieutenant, Kirk was a bookish nerd and terror of Starfleet cadets taking his "think or sink" philosophy course
fictionandtheatre responded:
#i love all of them but i love stack of books with legs kirk so i chose the tough grader #would LOVE a glimpse into that kirk honestly
kleine-snowdrop responded (on 2 February):
#It's always Kirk being a walking stack of books #I really want more details about his days teaching at the academy #Also this big old space square is my baby #So yeah
Spock is ashamed of his feelings for Kirk, and guiltily tries to explain why
dannyketch responded (on 2 February):
#jim. when i feel frienship for you. i'm ashamed #actually this explains a good deal of how i like my romance to be like... anyways
McCoy inventing HIPAA
star-temeraire responded (on 2 February):
#in this house we respect the autonomy of disabled people
talk-nerdy-to-me-thyla responded (on 5 February):
#actual ethical medicine?? #in MY 60s tv show??
The Gorn Did Nothing Wrong
howtospeakhovitos responded:
#i will never forgive the otherwise excellent strange new worlds for retconning the original gorn and making them evil
youngpettyqueen responded (on 2 February):
#THE GORN!!!!! #look I enjoy SNW but I am NOT forgiving their crimes against the Gorn #THEY WERE PROTECTING THEIR HOMES!!! THEY WERE PROTECTING THEMSELVES!!! #THEY ARENT INHERENTLY VICIOUS BLOODTHIRSTY MONSTERS #THEY WERE ONLY PROTECTING THEMSELVES!!!!!!
myboombsaresentientbeings responded (on 2 February):
#I'm choosing the gorn fact because i hate what snw is doing with them
kityana responded (on 13 February):
#the original gorn plot!! #i hate what they did with them in snw #the entire point of the gorn episode is to learn to respect them despite how scary they look and act #snw just use them as generic monsters completely missing the point
Sulu and Chekov refusing to just follow orders
isadora-greenhall responded:
#cheering for sulu and chekov for doing the right thing
landofalwayswinter responded (on 6 February):
#sulu+chekov two person union strike
More than one
chiemirose responded:
#i love all these details
officialbabayaga responded:
#literally mention tarsus iv and i am fully incapacitated #these are such fun facts though! definitely didn’t know most of these actually
vitabreva responded:
#monotheist kirk #didn't know original series had a yuri moment
mccoysaccent responded:
#i did the mccoy and dr jones one #BUT ALSO THE GORN DID NOTBING WRONG #THE WHOLE POINT OF THAT EPISODE WAS TO SHOW HOW YOU DONT KNOW YOUR ENEMY AND WHEN YOU DO YOU REALIZE THEYRE JUST LIKE YOU #IT WAS A GODDAMN METAPHOR #FUCK STRANGE NEW WORLDS
lavenderandlemons responded (on 5 February):
#spock being ashamed of his afection is a close second #but 13 yo kirk going throught a genocide makes me want to hug him so bad
bumblingbabooshka responded (on 6 February):
#these are all so interesting~! I love character details #The Gorn one is so sad especially with snw v_v
chaotic-enterprise responded (on 1 February):
#some of these I already knew but some I did NOT and I am FASCINATED
I replied (on 21 April):
Thank you! It was difficult to narrow down to these options, but there is so many more character details to chew on in TOS than I ever expected.
noggington responded (on 2 February):
#ty fir citing sources <3#i <3 fandom bibliographies
I replied (on 6 February):
Thank you! I considered not doing it because it makes the post so much longer, but felt I would be spiritually haunted by my grad school committee if I didn't include them, lol >_>
fictionandtheatre responded:
#i love all of them but i love stack of books with legs kirk so i chose the tough grader #would LOVE a glimpse into that kirk honestly
kleine-snowdrop responded (on 2 February):
#It's always Kirk being a walking stack of books #I really want more details about his days teaching at the academy #Also this big old space square is my baby #So yeah
Spock is ashamed of his feelings for Kirk, and guiltily tries to explain why
dannyketch responded (on 2 February):
#jim. when i feel frienship for you. i'm ashamed #actually this explains a good deal of how i like my romance to be like... anyways
McCoy inventing HIPAA
star-temeraire responded (on 2 February):
#in this house we respect the autonomy of disabled people
talk-nerdy-to-me-thyla responded (on 5 February):
#actual ethical medicine?? #in MY 60s tv show??
The Gorn Did Nothing Wrong
howtospeakhovitos responded:
#i will never forgive the otherwise excellent strange new worlds for retconning the original gorn and making them evil
youngpettyqueen responded (on 2 February):
#THE GORN!!!!! #look I enjoy SNW but I am NOT forgiving their crimes against the Gorn #THEY WERE PROTECTING THEIR HOMES!!! THEY WERE PROTECTING THEMSELVES!!! #THEY ARENT INHERENTLY VICIOUS BLOODTHIRSTY MONSTERS #THEY WERE ONLY PROTECTING THEMSELVES!!!!!!
myboombsaresentientbeings responded (on 2 February):
#I'm choosing the gorn fact because i hate what snw is doing with them
kityana responded (on 13 February):
#the original gorn plot!! #i hate what they did with them in snw #the entire point of the gorn episode is to learn to respect them despite how scary they look and act #snw just use them as generic monsters completely missing the point
Sulu and Chekov refusing to just follow orders
isadora-greenhall responded:
#cheering for sulu and chekov for doing the right thing
landofalwayswinter responded (on 6 February):
#sulu+chekov two person union strike
More than one
chiemirose responded:
#i love all these details
officialbabayaga responded:
#literally mention tarsus iv and i am fully incapacitated #these are such fun facts though! definitely didn’t know most of these actually
vitabreva responded:
#monotheist kirk #didn't know original series had a yuri moment
mccoysaccent responded:
#i did the mccoy and dr jones one #BUT ALSO THE GORN DID NOTBING WRONG #THE WHOLE POINT OF THAT EPISODE WAS TO SHOW HOW YOU DONT KNOW YOUR ENEMY AND WHEN YOU DO YOU REALIZE THEYRE JUST LIKE YOU #IT WAS A GODDAMN METAPHOR #FUCK STRANGE NEW WORLDS
lavenderandlemons responded (on 5 February):
#spock being ashamed of his afection is a close second #but 13 yo kirk going throught a genocide makes me want to hug him so bad
bumblingbabooshka responded (on 6 February):
#these are all so interesting~! I love character details #The Gorn one is so sad especially with snw v_v
chaotic-enterprise responded (on 1 February):
#some of these I already knew but some I did NOT and I am FASCINATED
I replied (on 21 April):
Thank you! It was difficult to narrow down to these options, but there is so many more character details to chew on in TOS than I ever expected.
noggington responded (on 2 February):
#ty fir citing sources <3#i <3 fandom bibliographies
I replied (on 6 February):
Thank you! I considered not doing it because it makes the post so much longer, but felt I would be spiritually haunted by my grad school committee if I didn't include them, lol >_>